home about us contact us

free scripts advanced scripts online tools great books web related tutorials contributed tutorials news archive geek toys!

help forum live chat help

Selected article

RSS feed   enewsbar Live Subscribe    Add to MyYahoo    Add to Google

Other HTMLfixIT articles:

by Franki

I’ve recently been reading the Oracle verses Google court case at Groklaw and I must say I am surprised at one thing. Apache Harmony (an Open Source Java SE.) has been around for a very long time, Sun has known for many years exactly what was in Harmony and who put it there and why (by their own admission) and Apache has been hassling Sun to certify Harmony as Java compliant without having to pay for a TCL. (Apache give it away for free so non free terms are difficult for them). Because Apache were not able to get a free TCL to certify Harmony was fully Java compatible, they never stipulated that it was. That doesn’t mean it’s illegal because the Java language is free, it just means that without the certification they couldn’t claim it was Java compatible, or use trademarks owned by Sun.

Not only did Sun never go after Apache Harmony (which contains ALL the API’s that Oracle is suing Google for), the then CEO of Sun (Jonathan Schwartz) is actually on record as saying Harmony was fine to be released as it was. Since Sun also knew that Harmony was under an Apache license (which is the same license that Google used for that part of Android), How can this not be viewed as anything but an implied license?

It goes further than that even. The same CEO is on record as saying he approved of Android and they welcomed the Java language being brought to a lot more people. In fact he will be testifying at trial that Android had his full approval a the time.

If the boss of the company who actually made Java (as opposed to Oracle who just bought Sun after all was already said and done) said on more than one occasion that Harmony was fine and legal as is, and that Android is welcome and they’d like to help however they can, again, how can this not be seen as an implied license?

Sun tried to make a popular mobile OS and failed, Oracle looked at it themselves and realized that they didn’t know enough to pull it off. Someone at that point appears to have decided “stuff it, this is too hard, lets just take a slice of Google’s pie.”

Simple facts (as I understand them),
Sun had no issue with Apache harmony with all the API’s in question under an Apache license and said so publicly and on the record.
Google uses those same Apache harmony API’s in Android under the same Apache license.
Sun (prior to Oracle buying them) also publicly endorsed Android on more then one occasion.
Oracle came and bought Sun after all of this happened and started looking for ways to monetize their investment. (In fact I believe ex Sun employees have said that Oracle were already looking for dirt on Google prior to the Sun sale even completing.)
Oracle are now claiming that Harmony is infringing and that Google is too as a result.

Is it even legal for a company that buys another company to retrospectively contradict their previous CEO’s public announcements when they don’t agree with them? I’d love to hear some explanation of how that is possible.

49 Responses to “Oracle attacks Google for $$$”

  1. George Woods Says:

    What’s going on here? Is this true? Unbelievable!

  2. assignment writing service Says:

    My guess is that since Apache’s goal was to consume an open source application of Java, Oracle’s conclusion to transition Java to open source made it unreasonable for Apache to pursue further development of Harmony.

  3. Online Dissertation Help UK Says:

    Yes clear about the instruction now fill the promising one to be discussed by instructor whole scenario I usually covered the idea to be delivered the stance since Apto ache’s goal available source Java application, Oracle’s development.

  4. Accounting Assignment Help Says:

    I’m Really Impressed With Your Article, Such Great & Usefull Knowledge You Mentioned Here

  5. Case Study Help Says:

    This Was A Great And Interesting Article To Read. I Have Really Enjoyed All Of This Very Cool Information

  6. Meat thermometer review Says:

    nice post. Thanks for sharing such an interesting and witty post with us.

  7. motion sensor light battery powered Says:

    Nice way. It is really very good actually. Every word of this blog is so good that I have read.

  8. ReFX Nexus2 Says:

    Good website! Its really truly for my eyes. I wonder how I might get notified when the new post is made.

  9. Help With Essay Writing Service Says:

    Oracle eventually filed a patent lawsuit against Google. now not a massive surprise. at some point of the combination conferences between solar and Oracle where we have been being grilled about the patent scenario among sun and Google we could see the Oracle attorney’s eyes sparkle.

  10. Happy Friendship Day Says:

    A best friend is someone who knows the song of your heart, and will sing it back to you if you ever forget the words.

  11. Nile cruise Says:

    The first post is always the reflection of what is to come after on the blog posting website.

  12. Aprilia RSV Mille Says:

    The Aprilia RSV Mille was a sports motorcycle manufactured by Aprilia from 1998 to 2003. The Italian supersport bike was offered in three versions, RSV Mille, RSV Mille R, and RSV Mille SP.

  13. Riverdale Southside Serpents Jacket Says:

    The topic is quite vast and you contrast it with good explanation

  14. I love u messages for girlfriend - Priya Mehra Says:

    Every person wants to propose her girlfriend and says him I love u.

  15. celebsfit at Keith Force Voltron Jacket Says:

    I am going to suggest this website to my friends because I got many well explained tricky topic from this website

  16. New Arrivals Jacket Says:

    I got numerous information here about topic and all point explained in appealing way

  17. mohit sona Says:

    This is my first time pay a quick visit at
    here and i am actually impressed to read everthing at one place.

  18. Driver Easy Professional key Says:

    Thanks for your article! I have read through some similar topics! However, your post has given me a very special impression, unlike other posts.

  19. 2 Way SMS Says:

    With 2-way sms, you can get customers to answer quick surveys and polls via text messaging. It may be the least bothersome way to get them to answer as compared to chasing them in malls.

  20. Acura nsx 2019 Says:

    Is giving its NSX mid-engine hybrid all-wheel-drive supercar a relatively thorough refresh.

  21. download your uninstaller Says:

    This article gives the light in which we can observe the reality. This is very nice one and gives indepth information. Thanks for this nice article.

  22. Download ableton live 9 full version with crack Says:

    Such a nice blog as seen experts content here, must build some great blogger.

  23. Online Assignment Help Says:

    For students help you just look at the Assignment help given by the assignment experts. Opting for our Online Assignment Help could be ideal for such students and they can get a complete assignment solution n from us.

  24. Zero movie download Says:

    Zero what a brilliant movie made by Himanshu & Aanand. It’s beautiful, fresh, fun and at last, it’s Emotional. It teaches us a life lesson too.

  25. Law Dissertation Topics Says:

    Nice article.

  26. Ableton Live 9 Crack Says:

    you can download the latest version of Ableton Live 9 Crack from

  27. Rebecca Virginia Says:

    This blog giving information of apache harmony and its related things.thanks for sharing.
    SQL Assignment Help Online

  28. Achat smartphone Royole Says:

    Achat smartphone Royole

  29. click here Says:

    That’s the exact question I have in my mind as well for many years now. How is that even possible?

  30. telephone Says:

  31. Says:

    the boss

  32. Best Essay Writing Service UK Says:

    Java language being conveyed to significantly more individuals. Truth be told, he will affirm at preliminary that Android had his full endorsement a the time.

  33. the boss Says:

  34. Says:


  35. the boss Says:

  36. heu kms activator Says:

    Thanks for share very helpful for me

  37. the boss Says: boqq

  38. the boss Says: aezrty

  39. Online University Help Says:

    I Personally Like Your Post; You Have Shared Good Insights And Experiences. Keep It Up.

  40. AssignmentAssistance Says:

    I Appreciate Your Efforts In Preparing This Post. I Really Like Your Blog Articles.

  41. Buy Assignment Says:

    The Leading Assignment Help UK Firm Offers State Of The Art Services To Its Clients With A Promise Of Delivering All The Required Work Well Within The Deadline.

  42. Biology Essay Help Says:

    This Is Really Great Work. Thank You For Sharing Such A Useful Information Here In The Blog.

  43. Case Study Help Says:

    This Is Really A Great Stuff For Sharing. Thanks For Sharing.

  44. Case Study Help Says:

    Well Thanks For Posting Such An Outstanding Idea. I Like This Blog & I Like The Topic And Thinking Of Making It Right.

  45. Case Study Help Says:

    Things Are Very Open And Intensely Clear Explanation Of Issues. Was Truly Information. Your Website Is Very Beneficial.

  46. Case Study Help Says:

    Thanks A Lot For The Post. It Has Helped Me Get Some Nice Ideas. I Hope I Will See Some Really Good Result Soon.

  47. Says:

    This Site And The Resources You Provide Is Really Nice Keep It Up.

  48. CollegeAdmissionEssays.XYZ Says:

    This Is Really Great Work. Thank You For Sharing Such A Useful Information Here In The Blog.

  49. Pay Me To Do My Online Course Says:

    We Also Share Some Information About Our Business

Leave a Reply

This site is totally free to use, you have absolutely no moral or legal obligations to help us continue.
There are however, some costs involved in running the site.

<random humor>
Plus Franki needs to get his girl out on a date soon.
</random humor>

So if this site helped you find your way, perhaps you could consider contributing to our costs. Whatever amount you feel this site was worth to you would be just wonderful.
Use PayPal if you do decide to share and help us with the costs and in appreciation for our time and attention, or alternatively buy a book from our Bookstore..

  Time  in  Don's  part  of the world is:   May 18, 2019, 7:44 pm
  Time in Franki's part of the world is:   May 19, 2019, 8:44 am
  Don't worry neither one sleeps very long!

privacy policy :: support us :: home :: live chat help
contact us :: forum ::tutorials :: bookstore :: Site Map

      Valid XHTML 1.0!             powered by Apache Server
Pic 3 Pic 3


CIGHTML Firefox Thunderbird ClamWin WordPress SpyBot S&D TheGIMP Apache for Windows Registry Cleaners More cool stuff:


HTMLfixIT Site Stats.

Browser Statistics
Internet Explorer 85.88%
IE 717.63%
IE 62.3%
IE 50.00%
IE other8.6%
Moz Firefox 3.x3.03%
Moz Firefox 2.x0.18%
Moz Firefox 0.x/1.x26.65%
Netscape 8.x0.00%
NS 6+/Mozilla2.73%
Moz Seamonkey0.00%
Netscape 4.x0.00%
Opera 9.x0.00%
Opera 8.x0.00%
Opera 7.x0.42%
Opera 6.x0.00%
Opera other0.42%
Safari Mac/Intel5.21%
Safari Mac/PPC0.06%
Safari Windows25.2%
Google Chrome1.51%

Resolution Statistics
640 x 4800.25%
800 x 60026.14%
1024 x 76836.55%
1152 x 8640.25%
1280 x 80011.68%
1280 x 8540.00%
1280 x 102417.01%
1400 x 10500.00%
1600 x 12001.02%
1920 x 12007.11%
2560 x 10240.00%

OS Statistics
Windows 741.55%
Windows Vista2.4%
Windows 20033.91%
Windows XP20.86%
Windows 20000.36%
Windows NT40.05%
Windows 98/ME0.05%
Windows 950.00%
Mac OSX8.03%
Mac Classic0.00%

New Windows Virus Alerts
also by sophos.

17 Apr 2011 Troj/Mdrop-DKE
17 Apr 2011 Troj/Sasfis-O
17 Apr 2011 Troj/Keygen-FU
17 Apr 2011 Troj/Zbot-AOY
17 Apr 2011 Troj/Zbot-AOW
17 Apr 2011 W32/Womble-E
17 Apr 2011 Troj/VB-FGD
17 Apr 2011 Troj/FakeAV-DFF
17 Apr 2011 Troj/SWFLdr-W
17 Apr 2011 W32/RorpiaMem-A

For details and removal instructions, click the virus in question.